google-site-verification: googleb374b228e150dee4.html
top of page
  • Writer's pictureJohn M Donovan

Overthinking Things

Back when I was attending Wabash College, English majors like me had to take three semesters of classes from the math and science department. I wasn't looking forward to any of them, but fortunately the school offered Physical Science 1 and 2, essentially the rudiments of physics and chemistry for us humanities types.

Among the giants of physics we covered in that first semester was Tycho Brahe, a 16th-century Danish nobleman whose observations of planetary movements were considered exponentially more accurate than those available at the time. What I found even more interesting about Brahe was that he wore a prosthetic nose made of brass, having lost his original schnoz in a duel with his cousin.

Along came the midterm exam, and I was every bit as prepared as anyone else who was depending on his attendance points to keep him from flunking. At the end of the test, though, was a bonus question: "Why wouldn't Tycho Brahe have made a good reporter for The Bachelor [the college newspaper]?"

Holy cow, I thought--free points! I can earn two points just for knowing the punch line to this joke!

But then I started overthinking it. The professor hadn't struck me as someone who would just give away points like that. Maybe he had a beef with the school paper. Maybe he'd been misquoted. Maybe he hated the editor and thought the whole thing was a joke. I thought of writing "Tycho Brahe wouldn't have been a good reporter for The Bachelor because he was a stickler for accuracy," but that didn't make sense--I mean, what newspaper wouldn't want an accurate reporter? I ended up saying something along the lines of "Tycho Brahe wouldn't have been a good reporter for The Bachelor because his painstaking quest for accuracy would have resulted in countless missed deadlines."

There. That made sense and it showed that I knew a thing or two about Tycho Brahe.

But then of course I hedged my bet and added "And because he didn't have a nose for news." One of those answers got me my two free points.

23 views0 comments

Recent Posts

See All

An Invitation

Hey there, readers. In an effort to reach more people more directly, I've started a newsletter over at Substack. This platform allows people to subscribe (for free!), so anything that seems like it mi

bottom of page